The unending despair of DHFL depositors


DHFL’s chapter saga has dragged on inside the nation’s insolvency courts since December 2019. Final month, the Piramal Group’s takeover plan acquired the Nationwide Firm Regulation Tribunal’s (NCLT’s) stamp of approval. However the battle could have solely simply begun for the victims of the mounted deposit scheme, a monetary instrument that’s speculated to be among the many most safe.

As issues stand, the over 70,000 depositors, who had been lured by the promise of marginally increased curiosity from a lender that was then-rated AAA by the score businesses, are observing a restoration of lower than one-fourth (23%) of the excellent 5,375 crore in deposits.

Like many different mortgage lenders, DHFL—among the many largest housing finance firms in India and a widely known model—additionally used to boost public deposits to diversify its sources of funds. Most of DHFL’s depositors are senior residents, who shouldn’t have every other secure supply of revenue and rely totally on the month-to-month payout from the mounted deposit scheme.

The decline and fall of the mortgage lender is a vital signpost—of the plight of depositors within the occasion of insolvency (DHFL was the primary monetary companies agency to enter chapter proceedings in India); of the lure of upper rate of interest promotions; of the dangers of constructing selections based mostly on YouTube testimonials.

“In 2017, I obtained a name from a DHFL agent who stated he discovered my quantity on AMFI’s (Affiliation of Mutual Funds in India) web site,” says Anadi Shankar Biswas, a 66-year-old funding adviser from Bhilai, Chhattisgarh.

Biswas says he and plenty of different mutual fund distributors obtained such calls from DHFL brokers who have been capable of supply their cellphone numbers by means of the listings on AMFI’s web site. The agent, he says, defined the options of the product, harping significantly concerning the increased rate of interest on provide, when in comparison with a financial institution deposit.

“Nonetheless unconvinced, I went again residence and researched (about) the corporate and its financials. It was rated AAA, had negligible dangerous loans and the mortgage ebook was fabricated from small-ticket sizes,” Biswas remembers. “In one other six months, not solely did I put in some cash, however I additionally satisfied a number of others to deposit in DHFL,” added Biswas, now one of many 405 depositors who’re combating a authorized battle encompassing all method of boards, from insolvency tribunals to the Supreme Court docket.

In February 2017, DHFL paid an curiosity of seven.75-7.8% for a deposit of 1–2 years. Senior residents, widows, armed forces personnel, its mortgage prospects and those that put in additional than 50 lakh earned a further 25 foundation factors (bps). Compared, India’s largest lender, the State Financial institution of India (SBI), paid about 6.85-6.9% (excluding 50bps for senior citizen deposits).

“For retirees, even 10-20bps further curiosity can sway their opinion in favour of a sure funding,” says Biswas.

Indicators of misery

The primary indicators of an impending disaster emerged in early 2019 when the net portal Cobrapost, although a sting operation, concluded that DHFL’s promoters had siphoned off practically 31,000 crore of public funds.

The modus operandi, Cobrapost stated, concerned handing out loans to shell firms after which routing them to different entities overseas so as to purchase belongings. Then, in June 2019, a score downgrade categorised the corporate as a defaulter after it failed to satisfy its bond reimbursement obligations. By November, the Reserve Financial institution of India (RBI) had outmoded the board and it later referred the corporate to the insolvency tribunal. A number of skeletons began tumbling out over the following few months.

For starters, a damning forensic audit report compiled by KPMG discovered that DHFL used to boost cash from banks for the only function of lending the sum to homebuyers, who subsequently put the cash into mutual funds. There was a gaping gap within the agency’s stability sheet, which was initially considered pristine.

P.Okay. Jain, a 58-year-old depositor and bondholder from Kota, Rajasthan, says a majority of his 20 lakh funding matured in September-October (2019), however he’s but to obtain a penny. DHFL, he says, was extraordinarily punctual in paying curiosity to all of the depositors and bondholders earlier than the liquidity crunch and asset-liability mismatch crushed the enterprise. After all, Jain isn’t one to lose coronary heart. He has been extraordinarily lively on the Telegram and WhatsApp teams which have sprung as much as deliver all of the depositors collectively. Each the teams have about 400-600 members. The boards mild up on the slightest trace of constructive information.

Late final 12 months, DHFL’s discredited promoter Kapil Wadhawan’s provide of 100% reimbursement caught the flamboyant of most of the depositors. Nonetheless, beneath the Insolvency and Chapter Code (IBC), a defaulting promoter can’t achieve again management of their agency. In impact, the one method to settle for the provide was for the collectors to withdraw from the chapter course of and attain a settlement outdoors the confines of the IBC.

Wadhawan’s plan was based mostly on a number of assumptions about enterprise efficiency. The settlement plan, which was compiled by the chartered accounting agency ZADN & Associates and submitted by DHFL to the RBI-appointed administrator, had an inventory of 10 disclaimers. One of many disclaimers learn: “The projected monetary data contained on this doc are based mostly on judgmental estimates and assumptions…about circumstances and occasions that haven’t but taken place. Accordingly, we offer no assurance, illustration or guarantee in relation to the achievability of the projections.”

The truth that some depositors have been keen to contemplate such a plan was an correct illustration of the extent of desperation.

Since there are investigations in opposition to the promoters, stated Ajay Shaw, a accomplice at regulation agency DSK Authorized, a withdrawal from IBC can be fraught with dangers as a result of “collectors may later discover the promoter’s provide to be perfunctory”.

Uneven distribution

In December 2020, a distribution mechanism was floated by SBI Capital Markets (SBI Caps), the advisor to DHFL’s lenders (largely banks). It was proposed that depositors be divided into 4 brackets. These have been: deposits of as much as 2 lakh, 2-5 lakh, 5-10 lakh, and 10 lakh and above.

The lenders instructed that these within the first bracket would get 100% of their cash, whereas the others would get between 24.6% and 33.4% of the dues. This graded method was voted out by the mounted deposit holders in January as they referred to as for an equitable distribution of sources and 100% restoration for all prospects.

About 69% of all depositors and 71% of the secured bondholders have as much as 2 lakh in DHFL, in response to information introduced by SBI Caps in its December distribution plan, a duplicate of which has been reviewed by Mint. Some specialists say that depositors at the moment are in for the lengthy haul, and some of them with a big chunk of cash caught with the mortgage lender are calling the photographs. The very best sum of mounted deposits—at 3,901 crore—is within the final bracket of above 10 lakh.

The therapy meted out to the bondholders was comparable within the SBI Caps distribution plan. In accordance with a bondholder who spoke on the situation of anonymity, many traders wrote to the trustee (an company that protects the pursuits of bondholders) saying that the distribution was unfair to these traders who’ve excellent quantities above 2 lakh and relies on the flimsy premise that anyone above this bracket is a big investor.

The ultimate proposal which was put to the vote didn’t make any main modifications to the plan, nevertheless. However the DHFL fiasco may already be bringing about broader modifications. The identical trustee, Catalyst Trusteeship Ltd (CTL), can be dealing with a newer case involving the Srei Group, an infrastructure financing firm.

In an try to guard the rights of bondholders, Catalyst Trusteeship Ltd lately approached a tribunal to enchantment in opposition to a proposal made by the Kolkata-based agency for a six-month moratorium on all repayments. “They may have learnt their lesson in DHFL,” says the bondholder quoted above.

A public combat

With their hopes of recovering a considerable chunk of the dues caught up in authorized tangles, depositors have been counting on social media to the hilt to amplify their grievances. It’s a two-pronged technique, which includes a battle in numerous authorized fora and a combat within the public area on social media.

They’ve already spent round 6,000-7,500 per depositor in submitting petitions and hiring attorneys to plead their case. Up to now, there are about 5 separate teams which have joined the authorized battle at numerous deadlines, collectively spending about 30 lakh.

“We’ve got appealed in opposition to the NCLT approval to Piramal’s plan within the appellate tribunal. We’re in search of a 100% restoration of depositors’ dues,” says Vaibhav Guliani, an advocate who’s representing the depositors. There may be additionally a simmering disquiet concerning the position of DHFL’s lenders within the committee of collectors (CoC). The first motive for the prevailing issues is linked to the choice to overwhelmingly vote for the Piramal Group’s bid of 37,250 crore, as in opposition to the 38,400 crore provide made by Oaktree Capital.

Whereas each might need been qualitatively completely different, depositors allege that even a further quantity of simply 1,000 crore might need been higher.

Depositors say that even when the Mumbai NCLT requested the committee to rethink the distribution plan, significantly referring to the necessity for mounted deposit holders to get a “honest” share. Nonetheless, all that the bigger collectors did was to readjust some recoveries between themselves and different collectors— a plan which they finally voted in opposition to as properly.

“It’s fairly unlucky that now we have to combat a authorized battle to get what we deserve within the first place,” says Biswas.

It’s not but clear when the depositors will obtain their cash as they put together for authorized challenges at each step. In the end, the DHFL saga is a vital reminder concerning the risk-reward equation on the subject of depositing funds outdoors the banking system.

As of now, solely financial institution depositors are lined by the Deposit Insurance coverage and Credit score Assure Corp. (DICGC) with the availability of a protection quantity of as much as 5 lakh. Specialists advise warning on the a part of prospects and counsel they need to be properly conscious of the dangers earlier than investing in non-bank deposits. On this regard, the DHFL case will maybe serve for instance and set a precedent amongst prospects.

“Individuals are lured by the upper curiosity on provide by means of company deposits however as we all know, a better return comes at the price of better threat,” says Jehangir Gai, a shopper activist.

Other than the non-bank lenders, company entities additionally elevate public deposits and provide increased returns than banks. Nonetheless, in the previous few years, India has witnessed a number of such corporates ending up earlier than the insolvency tribunal, together with the Jaypee Group and Unitech Ltd. In accordance with a senior monetary companies professional, a very good credit standing is one method to decide the energy of an organization’s stability sheet. However because the DHFL case has painfully highlighted, issues can go from dangerous to worse very quickly.

M. Vinay Kumar, a 30-year-old depositor, says that the DHFL episode ought to function a lesson to everyone. Investing in an organization’s deposit scheme for a mere 100 foundation level bump within the rate of interest is loaded with threat.

“We have no idea when these authorized battles will finish, however hope (that) it does inside our lifetime,” Kumar says.

Subscribe to Mint Newsletters

* Enter a sound e mail

* Thanks for subscribing to our e-newsletter.

By no means miss a narrative! Keep related and knowledgeable with Mint.
our App Now!!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here